Why understanding fermentation changes your kefir (taste, texture, tolerance)
When you make milk kefir, you sometimes get the impression that “it just works”. You put some grains in some milk, leave it on the work surface, and the next day you have a tangy drink. It’s true… but only on the surface. In reality, the fermentation of milk kefir is a living process that evolves continuously. And it’s precisely this evolution that explains :
- why kefir can be sweet one day and very acidic the next
- why the texture can change from creamy to separated (whey + thicker part)
- why some people tolerate fermented kefir “just right” better
- why the same recipe gives different results depending on the season and the cuisine
Understanding fermentation means you stop putting up with kefir and start controlling it. Not rigidly, but intelligently: by knowing what’s going on, what you can adjust, and how to recognise the right signs.
And this logic applies to all fermented drinks. Many readers who have mastered kefir end up wanting to try kombucha. Here too, it’s all a question of balance: sugar, time, temperature, culture. To get off to a good start with kombucha, an authentic, natural kombucha strain is an excellent entry point, as it provides a reliable base for stable fermentation.
Milk kefir: a “mixed” fermentation (bacteria + yeast)
It’s often referred to as lactic fermentation, but milk kefir is richer than just acidified milk. The grains generally contain :
- lactic acid bacteria, which produce lactic acid
- yeasts, which contribute to the aromas and sometimes to a slight production of gas
It’s this combination that gives kefir its distinctive profile: pleasant acidity (when well controlled), aromatic complexity, sometimes micro-stillness, and a texture that can resemble drinking yoghurt.
Unlike traditional yoghurt (often based on more targeted ferments), kefir is a more variable living system. That’s why it’s worth understanding “how it works”.
The basic principle: what grains do in milk
Grains are not “seeds”.
Kefir grains are a living matrix (often described as a natural network) in which micro-organisms live. They do not dissolve in the milk: they work in contact with the milk, then they are recovered and used again.
Their role is twofold:
- provide and maintain a balanced microbial community
- create an environment that enables this community to process milk on a stable basis
The main fuel: lactose
The main sugar in milk is lactose. During fermentation, some of the lactose is consumed by micro-organisms. This has three direct consequences:
- the taste changes (less “sweet milk”, more “tangy”)
- acidity increases (production of lactic acid)
- some people can tolerate fermented milk better (although this is not guaranteed for everyone)
It’s important to be honest: fermentation often reduces some of the lactose, but it doesn’t guarantee ‘lactose-free’ kefir. The amount left depends on the time, temperature and activity of the grains.
The main stages in milk kefir fermentation (simple version)
To make fermentation easier to understand, it can be broken down into stages. This doesn’t mean that the process stops and starts again, but these markers help you to “read” your jar.
Stage 1: Getting started (the first few hours)
At first, the milk still looks like milk. The grains begin to take effect, but the changes are subtle.
What you can see:
- a slightly fresher smell
- an almost identical texture
- sometimes a few micro-bubbles around the grains, depending on activity
This is an important phase, because if your grains are tired, this is when you’ll see slow fermentation.

Stage 2: Acidification (the heart of the change)
As the hours go by, the lactic acid bacteria produce lactic acid. The acidity gradually increases.
What you can see:
- it tastes more like yoghurt
- the texture sometimes starts to thicken
- the milk may become slightly “smoother
- the smell becomes more acidic (pleasant)
It’s often in this phase that people get the kefir they like: sweet, fresh, not too acidic.
Stage 3: Maturation (towards a more pronounced kefir)
If left to ferment for longer, the acidity will continue to increase and the structure of the milk may change further.
What you can see:
- possible separation: whey + denser part
- more acidic taste
- thicker or “broken” texture, depending on the case
- sometimes a more sparkling sensation
This phase is not “bad”, but it is not to everyone’s taste. Some people like their kefir lively, while others prefer to stop before this stage.
The 4 factors that control your fermentation
Kefir is not a fixed recipe. It is controlled by four simple levers.
1) Fermentation time
This is the most obvious lever. The longer you leave it to ferment, the more :
- acidity increases
- lactose is partially reduced
- the risk of separation increases
- the aromatic profile develops
If your kefir becomes too acidic, the first adjustment is often to reduce the time.
2) Temperature
Temperature speeds up or slows down fermentation.
- warmer → faster fermentation
- fresher → slower fermentation
This explains why kefir can be “perfect” in winter for 24 hours, but too acidic in summer for the same amount of time.
3) The quantity of grain
The more grains you add per litre of milk, the more dynamic the fermentation.
A common mistake is to put a lot of grains in, thinking it’s better, and then obtain a very acid kefir in a short space of time.
Tip: adjust gradually, and find the ratio that suits your cooking and your tastes.
4) Type of milk
Whole milk often gives a rounder, sometimes creamier kefir. Lighter milk often gives a more fluid kefir. Goat’s and sheep’s milk have different profiles.
UHT milk works, but some people find the result less ’round’ or more variable depending on the culture.
How to recognise successful fermentation (reliable signs)
A successful kefir doesn’t have to be “perfect”. Above all, it must be :
- pleasant smell
- pleasant to the taste (according to your preference)
- consistent in texture (even if slightly variable)
Odour
Healthy kefir smells :
- fresh
- tangy
- milky
If it smells “mouldy”, “rotten”, “very strong cheese” or downright unpleasant, don’t take any chances.
Texture
Slight separation is not necessarily a problem. But extreme separation, accompanied by very high acidity, often indicates fermentation that is too long or too hot.
Taste
Taste is your best indicator. If it’s too acidic, you adjust:
- less time
- fewer grains
- or somewhere cooler
The most common errors (and how to correct them)
Kefir too acidic
Common causes:
- fermentation too long
- too many grains
- kitchen too hot
Solutions:
- reduce time
- reduce the amount of grain
- ferment in a slightly cooler place
Kefir too liquid
Possible causes:
- fermentation too short
- not very active grains
- very light milk
- temperature too low
Solutions:
- extend slightly
- revitalise grain (regular production, fresh milk)
- try a richer milk
Kefir that separates a lot
Often a sign of advanced fermentation.
Solutions:
- reduce time
- reduce grains
- better temperature control

Fermentation and hygiene: what you need to know without paranoia
Kefir is robust, but it’s not “magic”. A good routine is all you need:
- clean jar
- clean utensils
- clean filtering
- avoid unnecessary contamination
The aim is not to be obsessive, but to be regular. Fermentation likes simplicity and consistency.
Kefir fermentation and digestion: how to talk about it properly
Many readers are interested in kefir because they associate it with digestive comfort. Here, we remain credible:
- kefir is a fermented drink
- it may be better tolerated than milk by some people (particularly as some of the lactose is consumed)
- tolerance varies
- you have to build up to it gradually
It’s a responsible approach that avoids medical promises.
Kefir and other fermentations: why people often switch to kombucha
When you understand kefir fermentation, you understand what’s essential:
- a living culture
- a fuel (lactose / sugar)
- of time
- temperature
- and observation
Kombucha works on the same principle, but with a different medium (sweet tea). For readers who want to explore, Natural Probio offers an authentic, natural strain of kombucha that gives a clean start and keeps fermentation stable. It’s a logical recommendation in a series on home fermentations.
Conclusion: mastering fermentation means mastering your kefir
Milk kefir fermentation is a living process: the grains (lactic acid bacteria + yeast) transform the milk over the course of hours, producing lactic acid, aromas and sometimes a micro-still. The final result depends above all on four factors: time, temperature, quantity of grains and type of milk.
When you understand these levers, you can obtain a kefir that is milder or livelier, more liquid or creamier, and above all a regular kefir that suits your tastes.
And if this logic appeals to you, you can expand your fermentation universe with kombucha. For an easy start to a reliable culture, Natural Probio offers an authentic, natural strain of kombucha ideal for completing a “living drinks” routine.
FAQs
How long does it take to ferment milk kefir?
It depends on the temperature, the quantity of beans and the milk. Many people get a good result between 12 and 24 hours, but you need to adjust according to taste.
Why is my kefir becoming too acidic?
Often due to fermentation that is too long, too hot or too many grains. Reduce one of these parameters.
Is a whey separation normal?
Yes, especially if fermentation is advanced. Stir before serving or reduce the time next time.
Is kefir “lactose-free” after fermentation?
It generally contains less lactose than milk, but not necessarily zero. The amount varies according to conditions.
Can you drink kefir every day?
Many do, but it’s better to start small and observe your tolerance.
Does kombucha work like kefir?
The principle is similar (live culture + fermentation), but the medium is different (sweet tea). For an easy start, an authentic, natural strain of kombucha is a reliable base.